Magic: The Gathering Commander Finder
Answer eight questions in pictures instead of jargon, and get six Magic: The Gathering commanders picked for you, combos you can see and a full 100 card deck to start from.
A Claude session once built me a Korvold deck that I still play. I wanted anyone to get that feeling without a long chat, so I built a page for it. The first version asked seven questions and handed back a long list. This one shows what every answer means, learns which art you like, and only then picks six commanders, with combos you can see and a full deck to start from. Try it here.
How it works
- Questions you can see. Every color comes with art, what it is good at, what it is weak at and a commander that plays it. Pick three colors and the page names the mix (Jund, Esper) and asks how strict to be, with a live count of commanders for each choice. Ways to win each show a commander that plays that way and what a game looks like, so “drain” or “combo” means something before you pick it. Even the card look you prefer is shown as a real card in each frame.
- Your taste in art. The last question shows real commanders that fit your answers, with more as you scroll. Heart the ones you would happily look at for a whole game. Scryfall’s art tags, which say what each illustration shows (dragons, storms, cities, skulls), turn those hearts into a taste, and every commander is scored against it.
- Six picks, not a pile. Each commander is scored on art, plan, colors and how easy it is to play, and each part is capped, so no card wins just by matching keywords. The six best, kept varied, come with bars that show why each one fits. The full list waits below if you want it.
- Combos you can see. Every combo is drawn as its cards with arrows: what passes from one card to the next, and the way back round when it loops. Badges say what it makes in plain words (“Draw your deck”, “Endless damage”), and one sentence says what that means at the table.
- The xs.dev combo lab. A script reads the rules text of every card legal in Commander, finds pairs whose abilities set each other off forever, keeps only the loops a player can stop or that win the game, and checks each pair against all of Commander Spellbook’s more than 120,000 combos. Most turn out to be known, which is how I know it reads cards right. The new ones are reviewed against the real card text by a Workers AI model before they are shown. They are labeled untested, and anyone can report a rules problem right under the loop.
- A full deck in about ten seconds. Pick a commander and it builds the 99 around it, in your bracket and budget, checked by Commander Spellbook’s bracket estimate and, below bracket 3, kept free of the lab’s new loops, which Spellbook cannot know about. Swap any card for the next best one of its kind within your budget, and the bracket is checked again by itself. Then copy the list into Moxfield, Archidekt or a Cardmarket wants list.
What I learned
- Defaults decide results. “These colors or fewer” sounded friendly, but it let a mono black commander climb to the top of a three color search. Making “exactly these” the default, and showing what the other choices add, fixed more than any scoring tweak did.
- A combo finder has to be strict. Reading “whenever this happens, do that” is easy. Knowing when it stops is the hard part: once each turn, a cost, a condition, a creature that comes back as a land. Three real loops beat three hundred false ones.
- A loop that never stops is not a win. Two triggers with no “may” between them run on their own, and the rules call that game a draw, or you draw your whole deck and lose. Nine loops the lab used to show worked like that, and the page told players to stop in time, which they could not. Now the finder asks who can stop it first.
- An AI reviewer needs the whole card. It once rejected a working loop because it read the front face of a card that only does the trick after it transforms. Naming each face fixed it. The AI only ever removes loops, it never adds them.
- Rate limits are part of the design. Scryfall allows two searches a second, so the page asks from each visitor’s own browser and spaces its searches. Commander Spellbook goes through the site with a day of caching, and the whole site backs off together if it ever says slow down.
Commander Finder is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Fan Content Policy. Not approved/endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. ©Wizards of the Coast LLC.